Sarah's Cookie Jar

Iconic cookie boxes with creative flavors and hand-baked quality

★ 4.8 (47 reviews)

Bakery

Cookie crafting is both an art and a science at Sarah’s Cookie Jar, where every batch is a testament to a lifelong passion for the perfect chew. Sarah has spent years perfecting recipes that blend tradition with daring flavor combinations, all while maintaining the heart of a homemade treat. Her journey began in quarantine, trading a local deli counter for a digital storefront, but the magic remained the same. Today, each cookie is baked fresh to order and shipped in the now-iconic Tiffany-blue box, a touch of luxury that does justice to the love and care inside. This isn’t just about cookies—it’s about creating small moments of joy, one bite at a time.

Sarah turns cookies into art with creative flavors and a personal touch packaged in iconic Tiffany-blue boxes.

Products

Social Media Links

• https://www.instagram.com/sarahs.cookiejar/